Book Giveaway and a Little Insight Into the Roach Sisters
IN THE BEGINNING, there wasn’t a thing Margaret owned, a phrase she spoke, or a gesture she tossed off that I did not want as my own. But smooth-haired, blue-eyed, skim-milk-skinned, even visually she presented all that I could never be, her calm to my storm of unleashed red curls, speckled hazel eyes and haphazardly freckled skin.
Until long into our twenties, I honestly believed she was the most beautiful creature on earth, and while my response to the visual that is Margaret arced and changed over those years, the fact of her beauty never did.
From our beginnings, our physical differences also extended to what we did with our bodies. She sat in the shade and she read. Throwing myself off docks, diving boards and tree limbs, I knocked out teeth, bruised my shins and stubbed the top off my toe as regularly as most people eat breakfast, always really meaning to come to the table clean, or at the very least, unbloodied.
Emotionally, nothing was gained in the comparison. She could be still; she listened, she learned. Were she a kitchen utensil, it’s a measuring cup; I am handsful of flour tossed into a bowl.
The real separation came when our mother’s mind went to battle with something and lost. At 51 years old, and diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, our mother and her illness produced different responses in her different daughters. Margaret moved home and moved in to help. I moved out. Margaret took up gardening, a pursuit I judged to be frivolous and decorative. I started writing about our mother, a pursuit Margaret judged to be an invasion into our privacy and not all that helpful.
Each time I visited, there was another dwarf specimen tree; the tall hedge behind which our now unhappy home stood was sheared down to 6-inches. Peonies flaunted their party-dress splendor. What was the use, I wondered?
I researched and typed and fought with the government. What was the use, she wondered?
We had a lot to learn about the other.
In time, Margaret learned the crucial lesson that not all custodial care – tending, cultivating, and nurturing – has to be for something that only loses more ground every day. And I learned to respect that. As I started seeing my work as that of memoir, she started to respect that. The resulting admiration is no mere graft, but rather the flourishing regrowth that only a hard prune can provide.
Between the two of us we’ve now written seven books, the most recent being hers, a marvelous look from her own backyard. She knows something about what can be learned at home. I would know.
Join me in celebrating her new work, The Backyard Parables. It’s her best book yet.
To Enter the Giveaway
TO ENTER TO WIN ONE OF FIVE BOOKS, comment here,noting in both places the name of another memoir or gardening book that you identified with. Tell us why, too, if you wish. I understand some of you are shy and just prefer to say “Count me in,” or “I want to win,” but if you feel like sharing an inspirational book title and a sense of the “why” behind your choice instead, please do; all the better.
Entries close at midnight Sunday, February 3, 2013, with winners to be drawn at random (using the tool at random [dot] org) and announced the next day.
Once you post your entry here, go visit Margaret and tell her I get it now, and that I love what she does.
Count me in….would love to win…reading one of your sister’s books right now (courtesy of my local library)
I adored A CountryWomans Year by Rosemary Verey. I found this little gem while on a trip to Maine and devoured it I think gardening is a gateway to the soul and I’d love read Margaret’s take.
Growing up in Florida where everything is “gardened” for one, it was only as an adult with my loving Boston aunt and her community gardens that I discovered my own love for it. And reading Wendell Berry in graduate school only fueled the fire. So Marion, I know you in person, your sister by reputation and following her blog eagerly….and, of course, I have my own 2 younger sisters and so can relate on that level. Congratulations to you both and I’m eagerly looking forward to more from the Roach sisters (and musically, I’m a big fan of the Roche sisters!)…
Many memoirs engage me, Katherine White’s ‘Onward and Upward in the Garden.’Josephine Nuese’s ‘The Country Garden’, ‘An Island Garden’ by Celia Thaxter, on and on. Would love a copy of your amazing sister’s book!
I would like to enter to win the book. Thank you
I truly love Tomorrow’s Garden: Design and Inspiration for a New Age of Sustainable Gardening by Stephen Orr!
It is good to know that differently gifted sisters can achieve mutual respect.
I will name five books certainly worth owning:
1. Fidelity by Wendell Berry – It’s a short story collection. The title story is profound. It sits on my shelf next to Wendell Berry’s brilliant classic The Unsettling of America which every gardener would do well to read.
2. Away to Garden by Margaret Roach, a beautiful book which almost made me become a gardener….but deer have prevailed.
3. Writing What You Know: Realia by Marion Roach Smith, on a shelf near Strunk & White.
Roach sisters!? Now that’s a pleasant discovery. Margaret is my gardening hero and I’d love to read this book. I am not big on memoirs, and can’t recall the last I read (can’t really count that James Frey, can we?) but I clearly need to pay more attention to the genre. Thanks for the opportunity!
Henry Mitchell’s essays.
Count me in!
I’m reading THE PURPLE HIBISCUS right now. Also liked KING PEGGY.
Three Dog Life anything by Rick Bragg and and the beautifully touching story in the Memoir Project about “walking our dogs around the perimeters of our lives.”
I love anything written by Des Kennedy here in Canada. Because he gardens in the same zone I can relate to his humour regarding successes and failures.
I have discovered the two amazing Roach sisters on the same day. What luck. I would love to win this book, though I can see that all seven of your (combined) volumes are going on my books-to-read list ASAP.
I have read many of the books mentioned here by previous commenters, though not all. I must say the book that sticks with me, and which have I re-read several times since childhood is ‘The Secret Garden’ by Frances Hodgson Burnett. I discovered it at quite a young age after seeing the Shirley Temple movie version of her book ‘The Little Princess.’
Although it is a children’s book, I love the magical, inspiring story, and yes, the sentimental view of a garden and childhood. The spiritual element rings true for me in my relationship with my own garden. I also adore the charming illustrations by the wonderful Tasha Tudor.
I have my own gardening memoir to publish, if I can ever figure out how. I hope it will be akin to Margaret’s.
I just read The Gardener’s Year by Karel Capek whose humorous insights showed me that gardeners everywhere share the same enthusiasms and frustrations, even in 1938 Prague. I cared for my mother after a traumatic brain injury at age 58 that led to seizures and consequent memory loss and personality changes not unlike Alzheimer’s, so I have much sympathy for you both.
Nature’s Second Chance: Restoring the Ecology of Stone Prairie Farm by Steven Apfelbaum. Spoke to me so deeply that I wanted to pack up my things and move out to Wisconsin to be ready to take over for him when/if he ever gets too old for it.
Some books that come to mind: A Three Dog Life, Let’s Take the Long Way Home, and Michael Pollan’s Second Nature.
Hi, count me in! Thanks!
Love your sis’s gardening site!
Also love the book, “Legacy”, by Linda Spence…it’s a beautiful companion when writing about your life.